Comparing Two Types of Electric Fence Energizers: Nemtek vs. Tongher

• By admin
• Category
• Comments (05)

Electric fencing is a crucial component of modern security systems, offering a reliable way to safeguard residential, commercial, and industrial properties. Choosing the right energizer is vital for ensuring efficiency, durability, and cost-effectiveness. This article compares two widely used electric fence energizers, Nemtek and Tongher, based on several key aspects, helping users make an informed decision.

1. Origin and Build Quality

• Nemtek: Made in South Africa, Nemtek energizers are known for their high-quality construction and reliability. Currently, it is considered the best energizer available in Pakistan.
• Tongher: Manufactured in China, Tongher energizers offer a cost-effective solution with decent durability, though some users have reported issues over time.

2. Power and Output Voltage

• Nemtek: Converts 220V AC to 8,000V DC, ensuring a powerful yet controlled electric flow across fences. This makes it an excellent choice for those seeking balanced security without excessive voltage risks.
• Tongher: Converts 220V AC to 12,000V DC, delivering a higher voltage output. While this increased power may seem advantageous, improper handling or low-quality installations may lead to performance inconsistencies.

3. Lifespan and Durability

• Nemtek: Lasts 5+ years, making it a long-term investment.
• Tongher: Lasts 3+ years, requiring more frequent replacements or maintenance.

4. Models Available

• Nemtek: Offers a wide range of models, including Druid 15, Druid 18, Druid 25, and Druid 28. These models are tailored to suit different property sizes, ensuring optimal security for both residential and commercial installations.
• Tongher: Comes in multiple models, such as TH STEDWARD WF, TH MARS, and TH MARS 5. While these options cater to diverse security needs, the product range lacks the extensive versatility of Nemtek.

5. Backup Power and Operational Continuity

• Nemtek: Can be attached to a backup battery, allowing it to function for 8 hours without main power.
• Tongher: Also supports a backup battery, ensuring 8 hours of operation during power outages.

6. Operation and Control

• Nemtek: Features a manual operation system using magnetic keys. Simply touching the key to the energizer turns it on or off, offering a straightforward yet effective control mechanism.
• Tongher: Comes with remote control operation, allowing users to activate or deactivate the fence from a distance. Additionally, a built-in mobile application provides added convenience for controlling the energizer remotely.

7. Monitoring and Smart Features

• Nemtek: Features an LCD display showing wire health, power status, and disruptions, simplifying maintenance. It supports connectivity with Nemtek Connect or third-party GSM modules for wireless control. A mobile application is available for remote control and alerts.
• Tongher: Comes with a built-in mobile application for turning the fence on/off and receiving notifications. However, it lacks advanced monitoring features like wire health indicators.

8. Power Consumption and Cost Efficiency of Nemtek and Tongher

• Nemtek (Standard Druid 15 - 18VA): 0.34 units consumed/day, 10.37 units/month
• Tongher (Standard TH STEDWARD - 10W): 0.24 units consumed/day, 7.2 units/month

(Power consumption of the device is calculated by watt hours i.e. multiplying the power of the device in watts by the number of hours used every day. Which in this case is 24 hours per day.)

9. Alarm System and Notifications

• Nemtek: If the fence wires are touched or broken, a siren sounds immediately, and a mobile notification is sent via the connected application, ensuring quick response to security breaches.
• Tongher: While it also provides notifications, users have reported instances of false alarms, which may cause unnecessary disturbances.

10. User Reviews and Common Issues

• Nemtek: Widely praised for its reliability, durability, and seamless operation, Nemtek users report no major issues.
• Tongher: While generally well-received, some users have experienced false alarms and power adapter failures over time, necessitating more frequent replacements or troubleshooting.

Conclusion: Which One to Choose?

Both Nemtek and Tongher energizers offer reliable performance for electric fencing, but they cater to different needs:

• Choose Nemtek if you prioritize:
• Durability and longevity (5+ years)
• Advanced monitoring features (LCD display, wire health indicators, GSM module support)
• Higher quality and reliability
• Better alarm system with accurate notifications
• Choose Tongher if you prioritize:
• Higher voltage output (12,000V DC)
• Lower power consumption (0.24 units/day)
• Remote operation via mobile application
• A more budget-friendly option

For residential or commercial properties requiring robust security and long-term efficiency, Nemtek is the better investment. On the other hand, for users looking for an affordable solution with basic functionality, Tongher may be an option, although with some reliability concerns.

See table below for side-by-side summarized comparison between Nemtek and Tongher:

Need professional installation at the best possible rates? Whether you choose Nemtek or Tongher, ensure seamless and expert installation with Smart Sense Technologies. Contact Smart Sense Technologies today for a hassle-free and efficient electric fence setup!